This summer we’ve toyed with triple-digit temperatures repeatedly, something that is increasingly becoming the new norm. When the thermometer on our north-facing, shady porch says it’s 100 degrees F, it’s time for ice cream! It’s peach season in Arkansas, so I can’t resist finding ways to use peaches. Why not ice cream? Today’s recipe is for a peach ice cream that’s not too sweet, letting the natural goodness of the peaches shine.
Making ice cream at home is easy, as long as you have lots of ice, a little bit of patience, and an ice cream maker. No, I’m not talking about Mr. Homesteader. I’m talking about an electric machine. I remember fondly the days that my family and friends took turns on a hand-crank ice cream maker. I also remember when we bought our electric machine. It’s the same one I use today, decades later. Still, if you’ve got the muscles and time, go for a hand cranker, and burn off the ice cream before you ever eat it!
Now, let’s talk about two crucial ingredients that don’t go in the ice cream. You need lots of cubed or crushed ice, at least one large bag if you need to buy it. You’ll also need rock salt, also known as ice cream salt. Some stores keep ice cream salt in the seasonal section, while others keep it with spices, salts, and baking staples. We’ll use about a cup of rock salt today.
Peach Ice Cream
makes about 1 1/2 quart
Ice Cream Ingredients
As always, you should be able to find everything listed here in organic form, so buy organic if you can.
- 4 egg yolks (Save the whites! Use them for an egg white omelet with seasonal vegetables, and you’ll have a light, fluffy, flavorful summer breakfast. Ask me if you want a recipe.)
- 1/2 cup sugar
- optional: 1/4 cup nonfat dried milk
- 2 cups half and half (or whipping cream if you’re feeling decadent)
- 2 cups milk (whole or 1%)
- 1/4 teaspoon salt
- 2 tablespoons real vanilla extract
- 4-5 ripe peaches
Method
Using a whisk, stir together the egg yolks, the sugar, and at least one cup of the cream in a heavy-bottomed pot. (Whisk in the nonfat dried milk too if you are using it.) Heat over medium heat, whisking regularly, until the mixture is too hot to stick your finger in and hold but not boiling. Adjust heat to hold it there as necessary. If you have a candy thermometer, we’re looking for about 140 degrees F, held for 5-10 minutes. Whisk more as the temperature rises. The mixture should thicken a little as the egg cooks, but don’t let the milk curdle! Now take the mixture off the heat and add the rest of the half and half, milk, and vanilla.
Next peel and pit the peaches and dice them. You can do this step in the early stages of cooking the egg mixture if you’d like. Add the diced peaches and any liquid they’ve given off to the mixture. Chill it well, even to the point of putting it in the freezer if you’re planning on making the ice cream in a few hours.
Is your mixture good and cold? Break out that ice cream machine. Using the method that comes with your ice cream maker, put the ice cream mixture in the cylinder, add the paddles, secure the top, and pour in the ice and salt, alternating as you add them. We let our ice cream mix inside, in the air conditioning. At 100 degrees F outside, the ice cream may never properly freeze. Inside at about 80 degrees F, it freezes easily. You’ll know your ice cream is ready when the paddles slow down and the machine starts to sound labored. Hand-cranked machines will get harder to turn as the ice cream freezes, so save your best muscle at the party for last!
Quickly scoop the finished ice cream into a freezer container, being sure to share the paddles with your favorite people before the ice cream melts. Avoid letting the ice cream thaw and re-freeze, as without commercial emulsifiers the ice cream can become hard. You can dish up the ice cream immediately soft serve, or let it freeze a bit harder for those perfect round scoops!
Our next dessert will be rich chocolate ice cream, but before that I’ll post a tasty ratatouille Provençal recipe, to help you use up your bounty of summer garden and market vegetables.
Copyright Ozarkhomesteader 2011, including photographs.

Looks and sounds (and almost smells) delicious! Fresh peaches are coming along any day here but, alas, no ice cream maker. I’m in the process of making a black currant sorbet today…that’s as close as I’ll come without an ice cream maker. (Which could be dangerous in my hands…) I look forward to the ratatouille recipe. It’s time to catch up with my veggies!
Eleanor
Eleanor, will you share a peach sorbet recipe over at Nourishing Words? I’d really like to see it. I looked into growing currants here, but, alas, we live too far south.
Hmmm….let me see how the black currant sorbet comes out first. So far, I can’t seem to get it to freeze up enough, and it’s very tart! Peaches might be easier, actually, so I’ll give it a try.
Wonderful! I’ll look forward to it, Eleanor!
And now I’m another huge step closer to purchasing an ice cream maker. This looks fantastic.
It is fun to come up with your own blends! Next up in the ice cream recipes will be that super-rich chocolate.
[...] Peach Ice Cream, because it’s hot Ozarkhomesteader | July 30, 2011 at 3:01 pm | Tags: Food, cooking, recipes, dessert, ice cream | Categories: chocolate, Cooking And Baking, cream, dessert, eggs, Food, frugal living, fruit, ice cream, locavore, organic food, peaches, recipes, summer, sweet things | URL: http://wp.me/pxeEE-UO Mmmmmmm. Peace ice cream. [...]
I thought this post was wonderful and gave it a re-post to 2,000 subscribers. Hope you get lots of traffic and new readers from it! Yum!!
See http://alternativenewsreport.net/2011/08/04/peach-ice-cream/
Kindest regards!
Chase
Thank you!
Gosh this looks so good. And to think, I’ve got all this goat milk and no ice cream maker!!!! Must do something about that.
Oh., Leigh, you have to let me know how it is with goat’s milk. I’m dying to hear about it.
This sounds delicious! The peaches we are getting now are so good. Enjoying your blog so much, come over to Granny Mountain in NW Arkansas!
I did visit your blog, and I’ll be adding you to my blogroll! Our area peaches haven’t been that big this year, but they’ve had great flavor. I’m off to make more ice cream right now.
I popped over to return your blog visit, took one look at that dish of ice cream and thought, WOW. Then I realized this was a July post. But you know what? That ice cream looks just as tasty and inviting on a chilly October morning as it would in the heat of July, LOL.
I know, Leigh, I’m so out of practice on blogging. I know I’ve missed great posts on your blog too and just barely started to get caught up.
How would that be for fall?
This summer Mr. Homesteader suggested a pumpkin ice cream, which sounded great to me. The experimental dairy at the University of Wisconsin had pumpkin ice cream years ago, and I still remember how the pumpkin and spices came together in it. I always thought it would be perfect for a fall ice cream in the South, where we want fall flavors but can still enjoy ice cream. (Now that I think of it, I remember driving through a snow storm to get a special flavor of frozen custard in Wisconsin, so maybe it’s always ice cream time.) I’m getting over a cold and still finishing the chicken tractor for our new set of layers (long story, which I will post here soon), but I’m thinking I’ll have to give pumpkin ice cream a try soon.